Motorgen - Automotive Events, Meets, Cruises and Forums

Motorgen - Automotive Events, Meets, Cruises and Forums (http://www.motorgen.com/forum/index.php)
-   Engines, Transimissions, Suspension, etc. (http://www.motorgen.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=98)
-   -   Head Studs vs. Head Bolts (http://www.motorgen.com/forum/showthread.php?t=40450)

Shaolin Crane 07-06-2012 02:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by enkeivette (Post 99924)
Is one of your foxes actually blown and running? Whats your setup? I thought you were just putting stuff together.

And Ive heard girdles are for strength too. Seems like this week you just cant type anything that I dont disagree with. (And yes that was a proper double negative. Suck that high school language arts teachers.)

not yet. Still tracking down wiring issues. But i was having head gaskets issues on the stock engine (which is part of the reason i pulled it and rebuilt it)

Like i said, girdles help for keeping your shit together when it breaks. Jeff (cobra912) snapped a rod at only 550rwhp (forged btw) and it launched out of the car and just about cut the block in half.

I have a girdle on the spare motor with forged internals, the sbf tends to crack at the front of the block near the cam. There's just not enough material in the block to keep it from going, the caps are small, the crank it 75% exposed its a wonder the block even hols the power it can

fiveohwblow 07-08-2012 10:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaolin Crane (Post 99890)
Tis true. Talk to me when you run your car as hard as Ron and I do. His car is a freak, venture over to corner carvers and yellow bullet and you'll see how many sbf dudes are having head gaskets issues.

It's difficult to define "hard", but my car is driven anything but nicely. Last run was over 100 miles and barely under 4k or 80 mph. I run the bitch hard. That's how the damned bumper needed replaced actually. My opinion: proper setup and tune, no need for head gaskets popping.

94cobra69ss396 07-09-2012 08:42 AM

I have about 90,000 miles in 6 years on my engine combo which makes 11-12 psi with a Vortech SQi S-trim and puts down 471rwhp. I drag race, autocross, road race, etc and it sees redline every time I drive it. I also use it as my daily driver and since I have customers in northern Cal and AZ that I drive to it's not unusual for me to put 600-700 miles on it in a day.

But like you said proper tuning is key as is the setup. My tune is safe and redline for me is 5800 because of the E303 cam. I have my rev limiter at the factory 6250 and it only hit it if the tires break loose. Even when I'm showing off doing a burnout I don't floor it so it doesn't hit the rev limiter.

enkeivette 07-09-2012 09:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fiveohwblow (Post 100036)
It's difficult to define "hard", but my car is driven anything but nicely. Last run was over 100 miles and barely under 4k or 80 mph. I run the bitch hard. That's how the damned bumper needed replaced actually. My opinion: proper setup and tune, no need for head gaskets popping.

I can second that, the only time I blew out a HG it was running super lean. But studs will def make it easier to drop the heads in place. Scratching the bottom of the head trying to get the dowel pin to line up always sucks.

PS, girdles help keep the crank from flexing. Not that there will be so much stress on the crank in a normal app that the block needs a girdle to keep it in place, like rocker girdles, but after 100k miles I would imagine there would be less wear. So Id vote no on a block girdle, yes on rocker girdles.

Shaolin Crane 07-09-2012 09:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by enkeivette (Post 100053)
I can second that, the only time I blew out a HG it was running super lean. But studs will def make it easier to drop the heads in place. Scratching the bottom of the head trying to get the dowel pin to line up always sucks.

PS, girdles help keep the crank from flexing. Not that there will be so much stress on the crank in a normal app that the block needs a girdle to keep it in place, like rocker girdles, but after 100k miles I would imagine there would be less wear. So Id vote no on a block girdle, yes on rocker girdles.

Ben mentioned adding a couple hundred horsepower capacity to a sbf using valley and main girdles. That mean you're taking a stock block ford from 500rwhp capacity to 700rwhp capacity. No, just no, a stock sbf block will NEVER hold that kind of power for more then a few miles. Not sure how you screwed up a rocker stud but i've never heard of anyone fucking up a sbf rocker/stud with 7/16 studs

Shaolin Crane 07-09-2012 09:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fiveohwblow (Post 100036)
It's difficult to define "hard", but my car is driven anything but nicely. Last run was over 100 miles and barely under 4k or 80 mph. I run the bitch hard. That's how the damned bumper needed replaced actually. My opinion: proper setup and tune, no need for head gaskets popping.

Its not difficult to define hard if you've seen Ron drive. I treat my car the same way, though I cant seem to just drive something without fucking with it.

Rons car is a freak but also not reving it helps ALOT with a sbf.

fiveohwblow 07-09-2012 09:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaolin Crane (Post 100057)
Its not difficult to define hard if you've seen Ron drive. I treat my car the same way, though I cant seem to just drive something without fucking with it.

Rons car is a freak but also not reving it helps ALOT with a sbf.

My point was its just subjective. I run my junk hard too.

I have been told by everyone and their dog that revs kill them also. I take mine to the 6200 redline I have set every time it runs. Not sure if that's considered high by all, but by most I guess it is *shrugs*

94cobra69ss396 07-09-2012 09:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fiveohwblow (Post 100058)
My point was its just subjective. I run my junk hard too.

I have been told by everyone and their dog that revs kill them also. I take mine to the 6200 redline I have set every time it runs. Not sure if that's considered high by all, but by most I guess it is *shrugs*

Depends on the setup. If that was my Cobra I would consider it high but not with my Chevelle. I shift the Chevelle at 6500 and I've hit valve float at 7200 during a burnout before I installed a limiter chip. Oh, and the Chevelle has a cast crank and 2 bolt mains.

enkeivette 07-09-2012 12:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaolin Crane (Post 100056)
Ben mentioned adding a couple hundred horsepower capacity to a sbf using valley and main girdles. That mean you're taking a stock block ford from 500rwhp capacity to 700rwhp capacity. No, just no, a stock sbf block will NEVER hold that kind of power for more then a few miles. Not sure how you screwed up a rocker stud but i've never heard of anyone fucking up a sbf rocker/stud with 7/16 studs

Add 13lbs of boost on a motor setup to produce 450hp NA and youll get a better idea how I screwed up a rocker stud. Plus I spin to 6500, rev limiter is set for 7k, and Ive hit it.

Shaolin Crane 07-09-2012 12:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by enkeivette (Post 100074)
Add 13lbs of boost on a motor setup to produce 450hp NA and youll get a better idea how I screwed up a rocker stud. Plus I spin to 6500, rev limiter is set for 7k, and Ive hit it.

3/8 or 7/16"? ARP or standard sbc? Cause ikve never heard of people having issues with studs on a sbf surprisingly.

Shaolin Crane 07-09-2012 12:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fiveohwblow (Post 100058)
My point was its just subjective. I run my junk hard too.

I have been told by everyone and their dog that revs kill them also. I take mine to the 6200 redline I have set every time it runs. Not sure if that's considered high by all, but by most I guess it is *shrugs*

If you're shifting at or near redline its not high at all. The blue car is nearly indetical to Rons motor so should run as such. The race car however is projected to have a 7500 rpm red line and a 7k shift point. I dont expect 100k out of it

94cobra69ss396 07-09-2012 01:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by enkeivette (Post 100074)
Add 13lbs of boost on a motor setup to produce 450hp NA and youll get a better idea how I screwed up a rocker stud. Plus I spin to 6500, rev limiter is set for 7k, and Ive hit it.

The Chevelle put 461 to the wheel NA and I also shift at 6500 and spray a 250 shot with 12.25:1 compression. I've never had an issue with a rocker stud.

enkeivette 07-09-2012 05:00 PM

Dont remember, and now you have ;) Ps, the only GM part on my engine is the block and the dist clamp. Theyre AFR studs, a top of my sexy AFR heads.

Shaolin Crane 07-09-2012 05:15 PM

AFR studs are just standard sbc studs. Nothing special about them.

enkeivette 07-09-2012 07:02 PM

Youre saying AFR studs are OEM for GM? :p

Damian 07-09-2012 11:01 PM

Question, I'm looking at replacing the main bolts. Looking at ARP bolts and studs, they both have the same tensil strength. Why are the studs way more expensive? Is it worth the extra cash if they have the same tensil strength? Common sense tells me no.

Vettezuki 07-09-2012 11:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Damian (Post 100120)
Question, I'm looking at replacing the main bolts. Looking at ARP bolts and studs, they both have the same tensil strength. Why are the studs way more expensive? Is it worth the extra cash if they have the same tensil strength? Common sense tells me no.

Guy briefly stated the same thing earlier, but:

Quote:

Torque Efficiency

During engine assembly or maintenance, a bolt must be installed by torqueing it into place. Due to the head bolt’s design, it has to be rotated into its slot in order to engage the threads and secure it into place. This process creates both twisting force and a vertical clamping force, which means that when the cylinders within the engine’s combustion chamber begin accumulating load, the bolt will both stretch and twist. Because the bolt has to react to two different forces simultaneously, its capacity to secure the head is slightly reduced and it forms a less reliable seal in high-powered engines.

By contrast, a head stud can be tightened into place without any direct clamping force applied through the tightening. A stud can be threaded into a slot up to “finger tightness,” or the degree to which it would be tightened by hand. Afterward, the cylinder head is installed and a nut is torqued into place against the stud. The nut torque provides the clamping force, rather than the torque of the fastener itself, and the rotational force is avoided entirely. Because the stud is torqued from a relaxed state, the pressure from the nut will make it stretch only along the vertical axis without a concurrent twisting load. The result is a more evenly distributed and accurate torque load compared to that of the head bolt. This ultimately translates into higher reliability and a lower chance of head gasket failure.
http://www.thomasnet.com/articles/ha...ead-stud-bolts

enkeivette 07-10-2012 01:14 AM

Starting to get silly, it is a budget motor. Id just reuse the old shit. If ford heads are defunct thats one thing, but bolts for everything else. Id even reuse the HG if it was an MLS. Ive reused mine 3 or 4 times, just copper spray it.

enkeivette 07-10-2012 01:17 AM

Piston rings too, theres really no reason you cant reuse them, especially if you kept them in order.

Vettezuki 07-10-2012 01:34 AM

I don't know what you're talking about? This is a technical discussion of bolts vs. studs, not so much specific application. You're assuming Snake only. The Snake is not so much a budget motor (probably around 500-550BHP with a roots blower) compared to the lemon Fox, for which duct tape would be sufficient if it works. Studs $55 . . .that's free. The rings are already replaced and installed. Done.

This was to answer Damian's specific technical question.

Shaolin Crane 07-10-2012 08:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by enkeivette (Post 100099)
Youre saying AFR studs are OEM for GM? :p

I'm saying afr studs are OEM material, nothing upgraded about them. Sbf AFR heads use to have chevy valves. If you want something thats strong you need to use something else.

enkeivette 07-10-2012 08:56 AM

Oops, thought that was you asking... Guess if I had a bigger screen LTE phone I would have known that... Ahhhhhh I hate my iPhone 4!!! Why did I buy such a slow piece of shit?! Sean was right!!! Baaaahhhhhhh!!! :crybaby: :crybaby:

enkeivette 07-10-2012 09:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaolin Crane (Post 100142)
I'm saying afr studs are OEM material, nothing upgraded about them. Sbf AFR heads use to have chevy valves. If you want something thats strong you need to use something else.

Hmmm... like stud girdles?

And I know what you meant, I was taunting you. Ha

Shaolin Crane 07-10-2012 09:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by enkeivette (Post 100146)
Hmmm... like stud girdles?

And I know what you meant, I was taunting you. Ha

No, like arp studs. The money spent on stud girdles can be spent on the studs.

Damian 07-10-2012 10:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vettezuki (Post 100127)
This was to answer Damian's specific technical question.

Thank you BTW.

enkeivette 07-10-2012 03:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shaolin Crane (Post 100147)
No, like arp studs. The money spent on stud girdles can be spent on the studs.

AFR studs plus girdles (cheaper, and no risk of deflection) > ARP studs ALONE (geometrically inferior and more than the $30 bucks I spent on AL girdles)

Shaolin Crane 07-11-2012 12:57 AM

Do the girdles come with new poly locks? Btw I paid $22 for my arp 7/16 studs. Which I am not concerned about fucking up

enkeivette 08-02-2012 01:44 PM

Oh ya, just ebay sbf stud girdle.


All times are GMT -7. The time now is 03:52 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.